Skip to main content
Scott's Blog of Doom!
  • Daily Updates
  • Scott's Rants
  • Headlines
  • Daily Updates
  • Scott's Rants
  • Headlines
  • Observer Flashbacks
  • Mailbag
  • Archives
Scott's Mailbag
Rants

Is it still 5*’s

By Scott Keith on 21 January 2024


Hey Scott,

   The almost 5* column on Rumble 92 gave me a thought?

Is it still the full monty if Hogan wins instead of Flair?

This got me questioning what other 5* matches would be totally different if the other person won?

Magnum Tully if Tully cheats to win?

Savage Steamboat if Randy hits him with a foreign object and gets a roll up?

Does the winner make the 4 become 5?
If Hogan wins it negates the entire story of the match so no, not 5 stars.  Magnum vs Tully was not necessarily predicated on TA winning as far as the quality went so it probably would still be 5.  Ditto for Savage-Steamboat.  The right guy winning was just a nice bonus.  

Comments are disable in preview.

Search

Recent Posts

  1. What the World Was Watching: Monday Night RAW – 08.19.96 Rants
  2. Mike Reviews Demolition: Witness the Power Rants
  3. The SmarK Rant for AEW Dynamite – 10.21.26 Rants
  4. The NXT 2.0 Rewind: November 30, 2021 – Joe Gacy vs… Fallon Henley? Rants
  5. Morning Daily News Update: October 22, 2026 – US Orders Diplomats To Leave Saudi Arabia Ahead Of WWE Crown Jewel Rants
Scott's Blog of Doom!
  • Email Scott
  • Follow Scott on Twitter
© 2026 Scott's Blog of Doom! Read about our privacy policy.